Home Main Forums General Discussion History Blinded by Anti Socialism: Ken Burns’ Vietnam

  • HomerRamone (429 posts)
    Profile photo of HomerRamone Donor

    History Blinded by Anti Socialism: Ken Burns’ Vietnam

    http://www.smirkingchimp.com/thread/shamus-cooke/75653/history-blinded-by-anti-socialism-ken-burns-vietnam

    The Vietnam War was a direct product of the Cold War, and thus cannot be told from a purely American/capitalist perspective, as Burns has unwittingly done. In the name of “fighting Communism” the U.S. government committed back-to-back genocides in Korea and Vietnam; a combined tragedy that matches the Jewish Holocaust.

    Millions of people were killed and two nations destroyed in order to “prove” that Communism doesn’t work. And sure enough, the ruined, smoldering nations left behind struggled for years after, receiving none of the reconstruction spending given to post WWII Europe.

    The merits of the Vietnamese version of “socialism” should be debated, but Burns allows no room for debate, since to him socialism is “bad.” However, Vietnamese socialism, while imperfect, allowed the nation to recover from obliteration and actually develop independently, and now the “mixed economy” performs better than most of the world, while overall Vietnam is a larger economy than several of its neighbors.

    Even with the above blemishes Burns’ film will be a valuable resource to active duty soldiers, who will find endless similarities between Vietnam and the lie-based, unwinnable wars they are fighting in the Middle East. Seeing veterans discuss their evolution from obedient soldier to war protestor will have its effect, while watching the lies coming down from president after president in the face of mass killing cannot project faith in the American military project.

    The international situation today demands that a new antiwar movement emerge that links arms with the active-duty troops unwilling to simply follow orders.

    nevereVereven, kath, Enthusiast and 3 othersPam, chknltl, Ichingcarpenter like this
    4SZKolZ

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

  • chknltl (267 posts)
    Profile photo of chknltl Donor

    1. I have seen glimpses of this documentary….

    ….and recorded all the episodes for later viewing. What little i saw appeared quite informative. I look forward to watching it but now i have a bit of a headsup thank you.

    I confess to not knowing how things have turned out for modern Viet Nam. I am pleased to hear that the country is doing better than it was while occupied by…well pick your occupier.

  • Enthusiast (9785 posts)
    Profile photo of Enthusiast Donor

    2. I have watched several episodes. It's on the DVR.

    Mrs. Enthusiast likes to watch her regular TV stuff. So I get a piece of Vietnam in here and there.

    I agree with the article. Although I was against the war as an 18 year old I had passed my physical and would have been drafted and sent to Nam if I hadn’t drawn a lucky number. That year they took to number 95, my lottery number was 97. That was one lucky number! Those were some crazy days.

    I can’t help but think the MIC and media would have come down hard on Burns if he had not towed the rope to a certain extent.

    "The NSA’s capability at any time could be turned around on the American people, and no American would have any privacy left, such is the capability to monitor everything. There would be no place to hide."  Frank Church "When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it." - Frederic Bastiat, 1848
  • BillZBubb (2663 posts)
    Profile photo of BillZBubb Donor

    3. Can't wait for Burns' series on Iraq.

    Everyone was well intentioned! We had to fight terrorism! Both pro war and anti war people were right!

    BARF!

    DemExit! Don't give the Democrats a dime. Don't identify as a Democrat. Drop Democratic identification below 20%. Only then will they support true progressive policy. Until then, corporate money rules.